Login      Become A Member      Contact       

Thoughts from the Byron Nelson Classic

Posted By: Chris O'Connell on 5/27/2009

Last week, the PGA TOUR was in Dallas for the HP Byron Nelson Classic.  Jim Hardy came into town Monday through Wednesday to work with Scott McCarron and Tom Pernice Jr.  I had Matt Kuchar and Matt Weibring playing in the event.  Both Jim and Matt Kuchar stayed at my house and we had golf “bootcamp” for 3 days.  Scott McCarron had a terrific week finishing T4th.  What was more impressive is that he finished an amazing 1st in Driving Accuracy (76.8% with narrow fairways) and 1st in Greens In Regulation (81.9%)!  That rarely ever happens because when a player is hitting his driver well, his irons aren’t as good and vice versa.  Why?  If a swing is more “shallow”, the player will hit the driver, hybrids, short irons, and clubs teed up or with a fluffy lie very well.  If a swing is more “steep”, the player will hit the middle irons, long irons, and clubs off of tight lies very well.  On TOUR, we usually see great iron players and great drivers, but we seldom see a player that excels at both.  A golfer only hits both well when his swing is perfectly neutral.  Scott is swinging as well as he ever has in his career and his golf swing is perfectly neutral.  He can hit all of his golf clubs, as evidenced by the statistics.  That is why Scott’s performance was so impressive. 

On Monday the British Open Qualifier for the U.S. took place at Gleneagles in Plano, TX.  I watched Matt Kuchar warm up prior to leaving for our Level 1 Plane Truth Instructor Certification Seminar and Plane Truth Amateur Golf School at Kemper Lakes in Chicago, IL.  All week we had been working on Matt’s hip movement in both the backswing and downswing.  Matt has a tendency to overturn his left side in the backswing which moves his hips out from underneath him and towards the ball.  This will put his weight too much towards the toes in his right foot, forcing the shoulders to turn too flat.  This causes him to be under his plane coming into the ball, creating enjoyable misses like pushes, hooks, fats, thins, and heeled shots.  Other than that, it works just great!  To fix this, we have been working on getting the top of his right leg to move away from the target line and towards the target as he rotates into his backswing.  He FEELS his weight goes into the heel of his right foot and since the right hip moves behind him, the shoulders have to turn steeper to counterbalance this.  If Matt moved his right hip correctly with a flat shoulder turn, he would in fact have too much weight in the right heel and fall backwards.  From the correct position, he just needs to unwind it correctly.  I want him to feel his left hip is the hinge of a gate in the backswing with the right hip swinging behind and towards the target.  I then want him to feel like he reverses it in the downswing, where the hinge is now on the right hip with the left hip swinging on roughly a 45 degree angle moving behind the golfer and towards the target.  Matt’s tendency is to reverse the hinges.  The left hip goes out in the backswing and the right goes out in the downswing.  This will put a one-planer like Matt on the outer circle. 

Matt’s ball striking had improved all week at the Nelson and his warm up session prior to the British Open qualifier was flawless.  He absolutely had his hands on the inner circle and could not curve the ball.  His golf ball went where he aimed it with zero sidespin.  I felt he would play well, but as an instructor, I never know what kind of result the player will get given that a golf score is much more than just ball striking.   In this case, he did have some great success.  Matt proceeded to make 16 birdies in 36 holes.  He shot 63-66 to win the qualifier by 2 earning one of 8 spots to play in the 2009 British Open at Turnberry.  This week’s PGA TOUR event is Colonial in Fort Worth, TX and is one of his favorite courses on the schedule.  Hopefully his good form will continue.  Keep an eye on him!

Many of our members have asked us to list some model one plane swings on the PGA TOUR.  Some have even requested swings of players who may not be household names.  I have a player for you to look for who isn’t yet a household name - Tim Wilkinson, a left-hander from Australia.  He has both a pretty swing and, most importantly, an effective swing.  Our motto at the Plane Truth is a quote from Jim’s mentor, John Jacobs: “The sole purpose of a golf swing is to produce a correct, repetitive impact and the method employed is of no significance as long as it is repetitive.” Tim pretty much sums that up – he is both correct and repetitive.  Last week, he asked Jim to spend some time with him as he was confused about a few things with his swing.  This was the first time Jim or I had seen Tim hit balls and after 3 correct and repetitive shots Jim asked me, “What am I going to do to help this guy?” to which I replied, “Be a cheerleader.”  Tim finally hit a couple slight misses, although it took a while.  At that point, Jim explained to him the cause of the few errant shots he was experiencing and how to fix them.  I’m not sure if Jim realized how important his advice was and the amount of confidence Tim left the lesson with, but I did because Jim narrowed his focus to address the important things in his swing to get him to hit the ball to the best of his ability and let go of all of the other crap that isn’t a priority for his swing.   Sometimes as an instructor, what you don’t say is as important as what you do.  He played decent in the Nelson and also played in the British Open qualifier that Matt Kuchar did.  Like Matt, Tim made the field at Turnberry.  He fired 65-67 to finish 3 shots behind Matt and in 3rd.  Keep your eye on Tim Wilkinson in the future. 

 

16 Comments

    • May 27 2009, 2:13 PM John
    • Good stuff. Thinking about which clubs are working vs. which ones aren't is very helpful. Sometimes when things are going bad it's easy to focus on the bad shots. Viewing things through the steep/shallow could help make an in-round adjustment. Although I think for the average golfer it's not very easy to figure out that you're shallow if you're both pushing and hooking and hitting both fat and thin. You'd think that would be a different type of shot. On that note, when your swing is shallow and too much in to out and you flip your hands to keep from going right and you end up hitting the outside of the ball and it goes left, what do you call that shot? It would be tempting to call it a pull but I've always thought of a pull as an out to in shot with a square clubface. If that's true, what do you call the shot I describe above? Thanks again for the good post.

    • May 27 2009, 3:41 PM Chris O'Connell
    • John - you are absolutely correct in that it is not a pull. You can hit the ball left two ways and both have the clubface hitting the outside of the ball. One is out to in and called a pull which will usually show a deep divot. The other way to hit the ball left is to swing in to out and flip the hands and clubface around, hitting the outside of the ball sending it left. That is a hook which seems to be a four letter word when watching golf on TV. It seems almost all announcers refer to all left shots as a pull when in fact almost NO Tour players swing out to in. When swinging in to out, the bottom of the swing occurs behind the ball which is where a player can get both fat and thin shots, leaving him scratching his head. This mistake will leave either no divot or a shallow one. Figure out which of the two you are and you have a good chance to eliminate your left shots.

    • May 28 2009, 6:08 AM Rick
    • Chris - for this type of left-going shot (swinging in-to-out and hitting the outside of the ball) is it possible that the ball does not curve (as we would think of with a traditional hook) but just goes left with a straight ball flight? This seems to be my bad shot lately with the driver and yet my natural swing path is from the inside.

    • May 28 2009, 8:08 AM Tom Greenwood
    • Great stuff, Chris. I really think Scott has the model one plane swing. As for Matt; are you saying that the feeling you want him to have is to shift his rear end around and towards the target on the backswing?

    • May 28 2009, 4:53 PM wes
    • Hip movement -- good stuff.....and it just happens to be the crux of my swing according to our lesson. Tuesday, I played in a KCGA event and scored 80 in difficult conditions (had two doubles), and then yesterday played 9 holes and couldn't do anything. The hips weren't working correctly, and I had the slap hook and block/pushes going on. Everyday, I'm focusing on proper hip movement.

    • May 28 2009, 10:12 PM Chris O'Connell
    • Rick - if your swing path is from the inside and the ball goes left, it is a hook. You are correct - it is possible because some hooks today don't resemble those of years past because of perimeter weighted golf clubs, square grooves, and low spin golf balls. Since you can only spin a golf ball in one direction and the short irons produce more backspin due to the higher lofts, you really won't see sidespin. The shot will look like a pull even though it is not over the top.

    • May 28 2009, 10:18 PM Chris O'Connell
    • Tom - I want Matt Kuchar to move the top of his right leg behind him and have it get slightly closer to the target in the backswing which will allow him to turn his shoulders into the zone. If he moves the top of his left leg out and in front of him the shoulder turn will be too flat.

    • May 28 2009, 10:53 PM John
    • Hey Chris, I don't want to belabor the point but it's interesting that you say get the "top of his right leg" behind him and slightly towards the target. I was the "sample student" at Core Basics in Houston. The instruction from Jim was get the right hip back and towards the target without straightening the right leg. First, is there significance when you say top of the right leg instead of just saying the "right hip"? And as far as not straightening your rear leg, what problems would that cause if you did straighten it? I didn't think to ask that while I was there.

    • May 29 2009, 9:41 AM Bob
    • I see someone posted Scott McCarron's swing in the video site. Does anyone have Tim Wilkinson's to post? Thanks. PS -Great Blog Chris.

    • May 29 2009, 8:42 PM tjschill
    • Fair to say one wants to turn INTO their right leg, not OVER their right leg ... leads to a deeper pivot... Drill I've used is to put an old shaft just outside my right shoe-- barely touching sole and extended straight up nearly touching my hip.... I then made my right hip move AWAY from the shaft (toward the target)-- thought was to create a GAP between shaft and hip... and also FEEL was to pivot DEEP and high with my right hip... Good thoughts???

    • Jun 01 2009, 7:21 AM DukeNasty
    • Bob, I just added two Tim Wilkinson videos (one is from 2007, but the other is from this years Verizon). This guy has a great swing! E.

    • Jun 05 2009, 2:04 PM Tom Greenwood
    • Chris, I get what you mean now re: top of Matt's right leg moving more towards the target on the backswing. I viewed a Hogan video and at address his right hip was blocking out a small tree behind him. As he turned back the tree appeared, meaning that the top of his right leg was moving to the left at the top of his swing. The angle of his right leg increased as a result.

    • Jun 12 2009, 1:04 PM Chris O'Connell
    • Sorry I've been absent from class lately. John, not much difference between top of the right leg and right hip. I prefer the top of the right leg because it gets the golfer to move the thigh as well. The right leg should straighten, but not lock. Locking the right leg could cause a reverse pivot or make it difficult to drive forward with the right leg and get fully onto your left leg. I feel the Tim Wilkinson video from 2009 is a much better backswing than the video from 2007. His arms are much more tied in to his body now than in 07'. Great post tjschill on the shaft drill and Tom Greenwood you are exactly correct in what you are seeing with Hogan and the tree behind him.

    • Jun 12 2009, 1:05 PM Chris O'Connell
    • Sorry I've been absent from class lately. John, not much difference between top of the right leg and right hip. I prefer the top of the right leg because it gets the golfer to move the thigh as well. The right leg should straighten, but not lock. Locking the right leg could cause a reverse pivot or make it difficult to drive forward with the right leg and get fully onto your left leg. I feel the Tim Wilkinson video from 2009 is a much better backswing than the video from 2007. His arms are much more tied in to his body now than in 07'. Great post tjschill on the shaft drill and Tom Greenwood you are exactly correct in what you are seeing with Hogan and the tree behind him.

    • Jun 14 2009, 12:02 AM Jim
    • Mr. Hardy ---Do you have future plans for a DVD of the "Masters Book" ? The visual DVD instruction works so much better for me than a book. Maybe a "Faults and Fixes" DVD ---due to the popularity of the instructional forums on your website. Thanks

    • Aug 09 2010, 4:59 AM Grant Glossop
    • Good to see Tim doing well. Fortunately he's from New Zealand not aussie :) Go the kiwi's

Leave A Comment



CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above in the box below



Blog Contributors
    Jim Hardy

   


Chris O'Connell
Level 3 Certified Instructor


    Mike LaBauve
Level 3 Certified Instructor

 

Archive
  Privacy Statement  |  Terms Of Use  |  © 2012, Plane Truth Golf Institute, LLC